CaddieTrail Guide
Seth Raynor died in 1926 at 52, leaving behind the most coveted collection of private courses in America. His template architecture — Redan, Biarritz, Alps, Punchbowl — appears on ten of the most exclusive and least-seen great courses in the country. Fishers Island, Camargo, Shoreacres, Chicago Golf Club, Yeamans Hall. Only Yale is publicly playable. This is a trail measured in decades, not seasons.
#1 on trail
Fishers Island ClubFishers Island, New York
Seth Raynor's 1926 design occupies a remote Atlantic island accessible only by ferry, blending naturalistic terrain with his signature geometric templates. Ranked among America's finest private courses.
#2 on trail
Camargo ClubCincinnati, Ohio
Seth Raynor's 1925 design outside Cincinnati ranks among his finest inland work, featuring faithful replicas of classic holes. Private access only.
#3 on trail
ShoreacresLake Bluff, Illinois
Seth Raynor's 1921 masterpiece on Chicago's North Shore features dramatic ravines cutting through nearly every hole. One of the purest golden-age designs in the Midwest.
#4 on trail
Chicago Golf ClubWheaton, Illinois
America's first 18-hole course, designed by C.B. Macdonald in 1895. This private Wheaton layout shaped U.S. golf architecture and hosted three early U.S. Opens.
#5 on trail
Yale Golf CourseNew Haven, Connecticut
Designed by Macdonald and Raynor in 1926, Yale features template holes — including a Biarritz and Alps — carved through rugged Connecticut terrain. Open to the university community.
#6 on trail
Piping Rock ClubLocust Valley, New York
C.B. Macdonald and Seth Raynor's 1912 template design on Long Island's Gold Coast. Classic hole concepts — Redan, Alps, Biarritz — executed on rolling, wooded terrain.
#7 on trail
St Louis Country ClubSt Louis, Missouri
Macdonald & Raynor design from 1914 featuring template holes true to their golden-age philosophy. One of Missouri's most architecturally significant private layouts.
#8 on trail
Fox Chapel Golf ClubPittsburgh, Pennsylvania
Seth Raynor's 1923 design brings his trademark geometric green complexes to Pittsburgh's North Hills. A rare, well-preserved private layout from one of golf's most distinctive architectural voices.
#9 on trail
Yeamans Hall ClubCharleston, South Carolina
Seth Raynor's 1925 masterwork outside Charleston delivers his trademark template holes — Redan, Biarritz, Eden — on rolling lowcountry terrain. One of the Southeast's most coveted private rounds.
#10 on trail
Blue Mound Golf & Country ClubWauwatosa, Wisconsin
Private 18-hole club in Wauwatosa with a classic parkland layout routed through mature hardwoods. One of Milwaukee's most established members-only courses, designed by Seth Raynor and opened in 1926.
CaddieTrail is the pursuit platform for serious golfers.