CaddieTrail Guide
Seth Raynor died in 1926 at 52, leaving behind the most coveted collection of private courses in America. His template architecture — Redan, Biarritz, Alps, Punchbowl — appears on ten of the most exclusive and least-seen great courses in the country. Fishers Island, Camargo, Shoreacres, Chicago Golf Club, Yeamans Hall. Only Yale is publicly playable. This is a trail measured in decades, not seasons.
#1 on trail
Fishers Island ClubFishers Island, New York
Seth Raynor's 1926 design occupies a remote Atlantic island accessible only by ferry, blending naturalistic terrain with his signature geometric templates. Ranked among America's finest private courses.
#2 on trail
Camargo ClubCincinnati, Ohio
One of Seth Raynor's final designs, Camargo was completed in 1927 after his death and ranks among his finest inland work outside Cincinnati — celebrated for the best set of par-3 template holes he ever built. Private access only.
#3 on trail
ShoreacresLake Bluff, Illinois
Seth Raynor's 1921 masterpiece on Chicago's North Shore features dramatic ravines cutting through nearly every hole. One of the purest golden-age designs in the Midwest.
#4 on trail
Chicago Golf ClubWheaton, Illinois
Home of American golf's most storied club — a USGA founding member that built the country's first 18-hole course. Seth Raynor's 1923 redesign of C.B. Macdonald's original Wheaton layout gives the course its template holes, from the Biarritz 3rd to the Redan 7th. This private club hosted three early U.S. Opens.
#5 on trail
Yale Golf CourseNew Haven, Connecticut
Designed by Macdonald and Raynor in 1926, Yale features bold template holes — including a Biarritz and Redan — carved through rugged Connecticut terrain. One of the few places the public can play true Macdonald-Raynor architecture.
#6 on trail
Piping Rock ClubLocust Valley, New York
C.B. Macdonald and Seth Raynor's 1912 template design on Long Island's Gold Coast. Classic hole concepts — Redan, Alps, Biarritz — executed on rolling, wooded terrain.
#7 on trail
St Louis Country ClubSt Louis, Missouri
Macdonald & Raynor design from 1914 featuring template holes true to their golden-age philosophy. One of Missouri's most architecturally significant private layouts.
#8 on trail
Fox Chapel Golf ClubPittsburgh, Pennsylvania
Seth Raynor's 1925 design brings his trademark template holes and geometric green complexes to the wooded hills northeast of Pittsburgh. A rare, exceptionally well-preserved private layout from one of golf's most distinctive architectural voices.
#9 on trail
Yeamans Hall ClubCharleston, South Carolina
Seth Raynor's 1925 masterwork outside Charleston delivers his trademark template holes — Redan, Biarritz, Eden — on rolling lowcountry terrain. One of the Southeast's most coveted private rounds.
#10 on trail
Blue Mound Golf & Country ClubWauwatosa, Wisconsin
Seth Raynor's 1926 template design near Milwaukee packs bold, dramatic green complexes onto a compact, mostly flat site. The first course in Wisconsin to host a major — the 1933 PGA Championship, won by Gene Sarazen — it remains one of the purest Raynor template experiences in the Midwest.
CaddieTrail is the pursuit platform for serious golfers.